generic viagra less order zoloft prescription buy viagra 100mg buy wellbutrin 300 mg forum priligy generico cheapest femail viagra online pfizer viagra cialis 20mg prescription levitra orodispersibile generico xenical 10 mg generic viagra masrercard cipro 500mg tablets viagra farmaci generici zoloft 700 mg nexium 20 mg otc generic viagra order levitra generic 10mg cialis 80 mg dosis buying viagra uk doxycycline tablets 500 mg buy mens clomid cialis 5 mg effective 35 mg prednisone levitra 20mg 12 preisvergleich clomid 100mg multiples kamagra cheapest price cialis tadalafil 20 mg xenical 120 mg romania viagra 10 mg fiyat glucophage tab 500mg levitra can 40 mg xenical online buy generic kamagra palace difference 50 100mg viagra buy viagra edmonton buy cipro fast cheap online viagra viagra generico acquisto prise cialis 20mg avis levitra 20mg buy xenical dubai wellbutrin 300 mg faydalari 250 mg. zoloft viagra 10mg dose diflucan nail mg zoloft 100mg pill werking cialis 5 mg strattera 40 mg cost cheap viagra thailand pomada zovirax generico viagra 150 mg prices inderal 40 mg propranolol hydrochlorothiazide 125 mg cp cialis online lloyds amoxil 500mg syrup kamagra viagra 100mg buy viagra indonesia augmentin es 600 generico diflucan online purchase priligy generico comprar significado prednisone 50mg viagra 100mg box cialis buy now zithromax 1000 mg nolvadex drops 20mg augmentin 228 mg dosage super viagra generic pattaya cialis generic propranolol 10 mg erowid viagra generico uk cipro 500mg pack buying strattera online buying wellbutrin online xenical 120mg tablete buying nexium augmentin bid 200 28 mg generic viagra indian 200 mg of synthroid propranolol sa 120 mg fungsi augmentin 625mg doxycycline tablets 20mg wellbutrin buy cheap buy doxycycline periostat 10mg levitra reviews levitra online generic kamagra apotheke online propranolol 60 mg dosage buy viagra lloyds 100mg zoloft dose buy cialis tablets 200 mg cialis dosage viagra online expensive cialis 100mg india viagra 10 mg paypal medicamento propranolol 40 mg liquid zithromax buy phenergan elixir online zithromax 2 mg lisinopril ct 5 mg prednisone usp 10 mg best generic cialis cialis original 20 mg. generic lexapro complaints cialis dapoxetine 80mg cipro xl generic viagra 50 mg packungsbeilage cialis online genuine lisinopril 20 mg prescription priligy online vendita generic zoloft northstar generic zithromax 500mg sublingual viagra 150 mg overnite cialis 5mg buy diflucan internet medicamento prednisone 15 mg viagra plus online nexium generic cheap price cialis 100mg online buy viagra zovirax cream backorder discount buy viagra buy levitra au cialis 5mg prix nolvadex 10mg tab clomid citrate 50mg propecia 5mg tablets levitra 5 mg tablets doxycycline cheap online define prednisone 10mg packungsbeilage cialis 20mg buy levitra pakistan order zithromax pfizer amoxil 500mg gsk cialis 100 mg dosage prednisone tablets 20mg free cialis 20mg anwendung xenical 120 mg buy viagra shipping generics for cialis viagra 50mg drunk valtrex generic usa cialis cheap overnight cheap cialis 10 mg lisinopril 10 mg eon ratio metformin 850 mg buy metformin 1000 mg generic wellbutrin target prices cheapest levitra augmentin 875 online 200 mg viagra cocaine rx strattera 40 mg mylan generic wellbutrin levitra 20mg forums generic research viagra propecia pharmacy online cheap viagra 150mg lexapro 20mg generic viagra pharmacie online levitra 100mg varmi generic viagra fgr 100 buy nexium singapore canadian levitra generic topsonline levitra nexium 40mg online legit cheap cialis nexium 40 mg mups cheapest genuine viagra generic viagra seized lasix online us flagyl er 750 mg lisinopril dosage 7.5mg viagra generica farmacia generic viagra overdose 5mg cialis canadian prednisone streuli 5 mg cialis 100mg review online viagra drugs tadalafil cialis 200mg generic viagra 150 cialis 20 mg testberichte phony generic viagra propecia become generic clomid 100mg 2011 nolvadex clomid buy buying priligy online prednisone 20 mg po buy strattera 100 mg generic levitra results zovirax online buy generica cialis Canada generic viagra yahoo cialis su generico propecia vs generic cialis da 5 mg lexapro generic benifits cialis mail order generic levitra au 3 50 mg zoloft 800 mg zovirax online purchase Levitra 20 mg cheap viagra lavitra prednisone 20 mg bid 4mg periactin levitra 2.5mg online propecia buy online zoloft online consultation xenical 125mg kjope viagra online buying generic lexapro nexium generic form viagra india order propranolol sa 60 mg diflucan buy europe xenical pills buy buy priligy germany viagra cost 50mg periactin 4 mg prix valtrex generic buy super cheap lexapro lexapro available generically generics of viagra viagra brand 150mg viagra generic brazil nexium 40mg indicacoes levitra 10mg alcohol kamagra gold 200mg 20mg of lexapro buy condom viagra cialis 365 mg generic viagra 120 gr nexium nombre generico nexium 40mg diarreia buy levitra manhattan online amsterdam viagra lisinopril 30 mg pill cialis 80 mg nedir cost cialis online nexium generic cheapest purchase doxycycline 25mg save metformin 500mg cipro 500mg wiki lexapro 10 mg medicamento cialis medistar. 25mg. nolvadex 20 mg prezzo two 20 mg levitra 6generic levitra cheap cialis generic indian china generic cialis doxycycline buying online viagra 150 mg preise metformin 1500 mg pcos viagra 250mg cialis 2.5 mg sale levitra 5 mg cost glucophage xp 750mg viagra 25 mg halbieren viagra online shoping zoloft generic forum generic valtrex australia generic lexapro appetite levitra atenolol buy misoprostol 200 mg cytotec ordering valtrex canada buy viagra.com wockhardt lisinopril 10 mg cialis 5 mg sklep strattera 80 mg reviews nexium 20mg nebenwirkungen mail order viagra cialis 20mg brand kamagra 100mg wikipedia viagra cheap mexico teva propranolol 20 mg prostatitis doxycycline 100mg 5000 mg viagra administrare augmentin 500mg prescription levitra 20 mg levitra 10mg price 500 mg zithromax chlamydia generic cialis net viagra 100 mg prescription levitra orodispersible 5 mg kamagra 100mg effets 600 mg zithromax celebrex 200 mg erfahrungsberichte lexapro cheaper cialis online florida viagra 0.25 mg forum nexium 20mg composition fluconazole diflucan 200 mg propecia online fake zovirax pills online lisinopril 20 mg mexico .5 mg propecia eod 20 mg of lexapro generic viagra kiev generic prescription synthroid buy metformin mexico viagra usa order cheap cialis 200mg clomid mg pct metformin online order prednisone tabs 25mg lisinopril buying generic valtrex cheap online cialis kopen metformin 500 mg day nexium 20 mg gastritis walmart cialis 5 mg pleasure cheap viagra medicine tetracycline 500mg cialis 20 mg nasil generic lexapro 10 mg generic levitra 40mg cialis generika 5 mg hydrochlorothiazide generic names buy levitra fast 20mg levitra canada synthroid for cheap generic viagra 72 doxycycline online order 150mg zoloft best online propecia lasix furosemida 20 mg doxycycline eg 100mg cheap blue kamagra order Cialis 120 Tabs generic 25 mg viagra xenical buy europe lisinopril online order cheap mexican viagra cialis 100 mg overnight lexapro 10 mg wikipedia strattera 80 mg flashback buy xenical cheapest cheap levitra walmart 0.5mg propecia viagra online legale clomid generic india beipackzettel cialis 10mg levitra online 10 pills cipro 500mg liquid cialis generic work buy legit clomid valtrex dosage generic dog 40 mg prednisone xenical 120 mg foro lisinopril 20 mg wheezing viagra online gel doxycycline 300 mg dosage generic viagra trial usa viagra 5800mg 200 mg clomid 3 follicles canada cialis order viagra online game 2.5 mg cialis generic buy zovirax 15g 100mg zoloft review 80mg cialis zithromax dosage 250 mg levitra 10 mg reimport levitra 20 mg tobuy valtrex 500mg packungsbeilage generic viagra eu lisinopril sandoz 10 mg generic viagra aust viagra generic customs generic levitra issues kamagra 100 100 mg cialis 1 mg order propecia internet venta cialis generico propecia online kupovina zithromax online order buy viagra placebo metformin teva 1000 mg thesecuretabs viagra 100mg cheapest dapoxetine economic generic viagra buying viagra scotland levitra professional buy viagra 50 mg tablets dapoxetine order online levitra review 20mg synthroid dosage .112 mg viagra 8000mg diflucan 150 mg capsules soft cialis 40mg buy diflucan medication zoloft 5 omg cheapest cialis capsule buy propecia cheap 100 mg generic cialis canada cheap cialis nexium dose mg erythromycin digestive disorders clomid 30 com 50 mg viagra 50mg rezeptfrei levitra farmaco generico cialis 20mg 30 tablet cialis 5 of 10 mg generic viagra stores prednisone 0.5 mg valtrex 1500mg tid e 20 generic viagra levitra 120 pills online synthroid .112 mg cialis europe generic propranolol 10 mg tabletta buy priligy india xenical generico chile 2.5 cialis cheap cialis 800 mg black buying fake cialis 500 mg valtrex dosage prednisone 10 mg usp viagra dokteronline augmentin 550 mg lasix diuretic buy generic viagra hoax 6 cheap propecia online online pharmacy dapoxetine diflucan 150 mg hombre costi cialis generico rx viagra 3000mg buy bactrim usa cipro online cheap cheapest 20mg cialis 40mg propranolol 10 mg prednisone high viagra 50mg wirkung buy viagra 25 mg cheap 150 mg viagra generic valtrex name viagra 25 mg prospect ordering authentic propecia walgreens generic viagra tetracycline 500 mg cost buy zovirax brisbane nexium 20mg buy augmentin dosage 500 mg metformin arcana 850mg lasix 120 mg iv doxycycline mylan 100mg generic cialis exporters viagra amsterdam buy synthroid .5mg online kamagra maestro propecia generic patent acheter cialis 40 mg cialis cheap cost 150 mg viagra india propranolol prescription online cialis 40 mg cheap 5 mg cost cialis levitra 40 mg purchase prijs cialis 10mg 20 mg levitra tablets cheap viagra greece valtrex online europe zithromax for cheap lexapro 10 mg tabletas generic viagra users clomid 3000mg viagra 100mg free 20 mg doxycycline buy xenical 120 mg benefits order synthroid pills augmentin 500mg tabs sildenafil viagra 50mg viagra 100mg 16 xenical 120 mg prices super kamagra 160mg levitra 10mg sale dapoxetine buy uk synthroid 0.1 mg daily viagra 100 or 50 mg cialis generique 40 mg prednisone 2.5 mg take cheap viagra generic viagra online issues amoxil 500 mg breastfeeding viagra buy adelaide propecia 1mg india isralie generic viagra cheapest lasix online 30 mg cialis safety 20 mg viagra wellbutrin 300 xl generics strongest 150mg viagra buy propecia pills to buy cialis erythromycin 250 mg iv Buy Levitra pill cialis 28 5mg buying lisinopril online zithromax 250 mg azithromycin generic cialis 4 tablets bula bactrim generico strattera cost 40 mg
Consulting Core Services
On-Site Training

GCA can orient the course to any  number of topics but typical ones have included:

  • Basics of the Federal Acquisition Regulation
  • FAR Cost Principles
  • Cost Accounting Standards
  • Working with DCAA
Sample Download

Click to download and view a sample of a recent issue of the GCA REPORT.
Click to download and view  a sample of a recent issue of the GCA DIGEST.

 

Contact Us

Don't hesitate to contact us if you have any questions, comments, suggestions, or problems with registration.

Phone: 1-925-362-0712

Fax: 925-362-0806

Email GCA

Subscriber Login

Path: Consulting Services arrow Report & Digest arrow GCA Digest Articles arrow GCA Digest 1998 arrow Alternatives for the Accounting Treatment of Fringe Benefits

Alternatives for the Accounting Treatment of Fringe Benefits

(Editor’s Note. The firm utilizing only full time employees who are paid generous fringe benefits are becoming the exception rather than the rule. The tough competitive environment of the government market are requiring increasing usage of mixed employment/contract relationships where, for example, temporary and/or offsite employees receiving lower fringe benefits, requiring lower facility and support costs, etc provide opportunities to offer the government lower prices based on lower indirect costs. Our consulting work helping organizations change their direct and indirect rate structure leads us to the unmistakable conclusion that each firm is different and requires a carefully designed approach. We have found the following article in the August CP&A Report by Darrell Oyer, a long time Government contracts consultant and principle of the Darrell J. Oyer & Company, intriguing for illustrating some alternative approaches.)

Fringe benefits costs as a percentage of direct labor has increased substantially in the last ten years. New employment arrangements altering the composition of the workforce has also caused potential variations in indirect cost rates. A brief review of FAR and CAS allocation rules precede a discussion of alternative treatment of fringe benefit costs.

Definition of Fringe Benefits

Fringe benefits are allowances and services provided by a contractor to its employees as compensation in addition to regular wages and salaries. They generally include costs of paid absences for vacations, sick leave, holidays and military leave, employee insurance and supplemental unemployment benefit tax. The US Chamber of Commerce adds (1) legally required payments such as employee FICA taxes (2) retirement and savings plan payments, profit sharing, stock bonuses, Employee Stock Option Plans and defined-benefit and defined contribution pension plans (3) life insurance and death benefit payments (4) medical and medically related payments (5) paid rest periods and (6) miscellaneous benefits such as discount on company products and services, education expense, child care and employee meals.

Allowability

FAR 31.205-6(m) makes the costs of fringe benefits generally allowable to the extent they are reasonable, required by law, employee-employer agreements or are established policy of the contractor. Costs of several types of fringe benefits are subject to separate, detailed allowability criteria (e.g. employee rebate and discount (unallowable), hours and incentive compensation (allowable subject to specified purpose and documentation), pension plans (allowable if computed according to CAS 412 and 413)).

Allocability

FAR 31.201-4 provides general guidance to cost allocations: "a cost is allocable if it is assignable or chargeable to one or more cost objectives on the basis of relative benefits received or other equitable relationship". Since it is difficult to identify fringe benefit costs to a specific contract the allocation criterion is whether a fringe expense benefits both the contract and other work and can be distributed to them in reasonable proportion to the benefits received. FAR 31.203 refines guidelines on allocating indirect costs by stipulating "homogeneous pools" of costs that can be allocated to separate contracts on a similar base should be accumulated while excessive cost grouping may be avoided if substantially similar results are achieved.

The allocation rules provide a wide range of choices for pooling and allocating fringe benefits. The guidance indicates contractors should consider whether the cost pool or pools are homogeneous. If fringe benefits vary substantially between full time and say, less than full time or field personnel, separate fringe pools might be necessary to achieve homogeneous grouping. FAR 31.203(b), on the other hand, stresses it is not necessary to proliferate pools to achieve perfect cost allocation.

Allocation Base

A direct labor dollar base is the usual choice for allocating fringe benefit costs and certainly the preferred choice of government auditors. A different allocation base (e.g. labor hours) may be justified when some fringe benefit costs vary by number of employees (e.g. fixed medical cost) or salary level (e.g. pension). Two separate pools with different bases are usually frowned upon for providing excess complexity with little added benefit.

Cost Pool Alternatives

When a company has primarily full time employees there are various methods of pooling fringe benefits that can yield very different rates and pose various levels of complexity. Fringe benefit costs are usually included as (1) on of many cost elements in various overhead and/or G&A pools or (2) in various separate fringe benefit pools.

Inclusion in the Indirect Cost Pool. Frequently, fringe benefit costs are accumulated with other indirect costs in an appropriate pool such as manufacturing overhead, engineering overhead or general and administrative (G&A). The fringe benefits for both direct and indirect labor are usually included.

The primary benefit of this approach is its simplicity. Lumping all indirect costs including fringe benefits into one or two pools is quite easy. There are two major disadvantages to this approach: (1) fringe benefit costs are not easily identifiable and hence easily monitored and controlled and (2) a higher indirect cost rate results in contrast to including fringe benefits and or other indirect costs in separate pools. For example, an indirect rate of 138% may be viewed more unfavorably than a 100% overhead rate and a 38% fringe benefit rate. As an added incentive, an even lower overhead rate can be made to appear if "direct labor costs" are defined as direct labor dollars plus applied fringe benefit costs.

Allocation of Separate Fringe Cost Pool. A contractor may decide to establish a separate fringe benefit pool to focus management attention of this important cost, to lower indirect cost rates or achieve more precision in its cost allocation methods. Once this decision is made, the contractor must then decide which costs are included in the fringe benefit pool and which costs are in the base.

The discussion below assumes two categories of labor: direct employees who work both direct and indirect functions and indirect employees who work only indirect functions.

Total Fringe Benefits (for direct and indirect labor) with a Direct Labor Base of Direct Employees. If all fringe benefits are in the pool and divided by only direct labor, this approach will yield a high fringe benefits rate because the numerator (total benefits for all employees) is divided by a lower denominator (direct labor only).

Fringe Benefits Costs for Direct Labor Only with a Direct Labor Base of Direct Employees. The lower numerator (fringe benefits for only direct labor) divided over the direct labor base will tend to lower the fringe benefit rate. One problem of this approach is how to handle the fringe benefits of direct labor employees when they perform indirect rate functions (e.g. attending training, idle time).

Fringe Benefits Costs for Direct Labor Only with a Direct Labor Plus Indirect Labor of Direct Employees. Calculate separate fringe benefit rates for direct and indirect employees. When direct employees work directly their fringe benefits are in effect charged to the job worked while when charging indirect, their fringe benefits are charged to an overhead pool like the indirect employees. The advantage of greater precision and a lower fringe benefit is offset against more detailed recordkeeping.

Allocation Through Intermediate Cost Pool. Combine all fringe benefits for all employees in one intermediate cost pool and allocate them on a base of total labor dollars of both direct and indirect employees. Fringe benefit costs are then, in turn, charged either to cost objectives for direct labor or other indirect cost pools. This results in a lower fringe benefit rate and is easy to use but can cause some cost distortion if some employees receive significantly greater salaries and greater fringe benefits (e.g. executives). The distortion can be minimized if fringe benefit rates are similar for all employees or the dollar differences are minimal.

Multiple Fringe Benefit Cost Pools By Employee Category

The increased use of less than full-time employees has created a need for more sophisticated accounting. The use of these employees has created real cost savings (e.g. lower fringe benefits, less support, reductions in idle time disguised as other activities) and contractors need to translate these savings into lower indirect rates for pricing purposes. Full time employees may receive all fringe benefits such as health insurance, vacation, and statutory payroll taxes, part time employees may receive limited fringe benefits such as vacation and statutory payroll taxes while temporary employees may receive only statutory taxes.

One solution for accounting for these varied fringe benefits is to account for them in layers or tiers. As the Table 1 below indicates, the first fringe benefits pool or tier consists of statutory fringe benefits that all employees receive. The second fringe benefit tier could consist of those benefits available to part time and full time employees while the third tier consists of those benefits received only by full time employees. Table 2 illustrates the resulting fringe benefit rate for each class of employee. Contractors can bid temporary employees at 6.93%, part-time employees at 19.43% and full time employees at the full fringe benefit rate of 37.75%.

Multiple fringe benefit pools can also be useful if benefits vary for any reason between different organizational units or facilities. For example, an organization with multistate locations where state employment taxes or different union agreements may require establishing multiple fringe benefit cost pools.

(Editor’s Note. Contractors fully covered by CAS should be aware that changes to their methods or techniques of allocating fringe benefits will likely be considered a change to an accounting practice requiring altering the disclosure statement and possibly triggering the need for a cost impact proposal and negotiating a price adjustments on CAS covered contracts. On the other hand, we have seen instances of a different treatment of fringe benefits by new categories of employees considered as an adoption of a new accounting practice, averting the claim of a change to an old practice. This discussion is beyond the scope of this article and competent CAS experts should be consulted.)

{TAG_FORM_TITLE}

To discuss your needs, contact Bill Lennett, Principal, at 1-925-362-0712 or email him at This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it .

*
 
*
 
*
 
 
*
 
 

 
GCA Subscription
REPORT FEATURES
  • New Developments-Rule Changes, New Guidelines, Court Decisions
  • Feature article for Small/New Contractors
  • Practical Q&A Sections

Download & View Sample


DIGEST FEATURES
  • Experts' Discussion of "HOT" Contracting Issues
  • Analyzing a Cost Principle or Cost Accounting Standard
  • Pricing Strategies
  • Case Studies on Challenges to Government Findings

Download & View Sample


SUBSCRIBER BENEFITS
  • Free use of our "Ask the Experts" panel where subscribers can submit questions to or chat with our network of eminent consultants and attorneys.
  • Electronic access to all prior newsletters through 2000. We provide state-of-the-art word search Word and linked electronic index to all articles.
  • Mailed hard copies and electronic versions will provide timely access to all newsletters.

 Learn More

 Subscribe