pharmacy 365 limited estradiol cream cost online viagra purchase india generic augmentin advair generic venlor buy canada zithromax oral suspension how to buy blueberry 100 viagra opinie acai 100 review where to purchase luvox is generic compazine effective genuine neurontin 100mg buy levofloxacin online tamoxifen without a prescription from canada ciplox canadian pharmacy ralista usa cvs prices zithromax costa rica what is celexa lipitor birth control online canada flagyl forte 500 mg obat apa where is merlin filmed in wales seroflo echeck doxazosin free shipping generic uk paypal starlix decadron online pharmacy uk cialis coupons for walmart cialis online pharmacy singapore buy cyklokapron mg where can i buy accutane for acne betoptic s generic equivalent order citalopram online no presctiption medicare viagra group pyridium refill pack where to buy trimix online micronase from europe wholesale drugstore cosmetics over the counter pain meds for dogs estradiol levels pregnancy naprosyn discount medications rogaine 2 without script free coupon for lopressor diflucan buy online ireland eltroxin 1800 pet meds canada buy adalat 30 0nline no prescription web pharmacy canada purple pharmacy mexico i want to pay some vermox can you get zovirax fucidin h cream ringworm can your buy levitra plus in ireland viagra where to buy benadryl mechanism action allopurinol treatment gout is it legal to order canadian nolvadex wellbutrin xl reviews 2012 buying acticin purchase asacol canada lithium without prescription canada real propecia results how much is a prescription of lexapro low cost alternative to lipitor prozac withdrawal length trental drug store online female viagra canadian pharmacy zoloft for sale prescription drugs online no prescription needed best price for real singulair augmentin forte australia buy viagra pfizer uk buy chloromycetin boots pharmacy drug prices lisinopril purchase finasteride cheap propecia i pill furosemide website what is ciprofloxacin hcl 500mg tab buy minipress mg online allopurinol where to get buy xbox live gold online rogaine 2 online in usa isoniazid medication for tuberculosis doxycycline vs. minocycline for the management of acne pariet medicine online taking 2mg propecia buy generic didronel online viagra plus pas cher italie doxycycline acne timeline sominex legal us what are the side effects of keppra in children alli price comparison buy eulexin without a prescription from canadian pharmacy what are the long term side effects of lasix avodart india sale generic sumycin buy canada how to use astelin keppra in croatia where can i buy carafate suspension best vytorin prices where to purchase diabecon comprar omnicef original albendazole in croatia comprar dramamine pela internet cytoxan by mail estrace ordering no prescription buy zovirax tablets side effects of requip tablets biaxin xl patient reviews how to use trileptal bupropion hcl drug class purchase differin nootropil pills drugstore where purchase clomid where can i buy lipitor in canada trileptal no prescription mirapex dosage strengths buy levaquin hong kong periactin dosage for weight gain in children uk version of silagra buy phenergan online with no prescription discount drugs amantadine hydrochloride paroxetine suppositories buy omifin 50 mg infertility trandate generic canada buy cialis soft 100 what does synthroid 50 mcg look like canada order female viagra buy flagyl er with no rx is it illegal to order generic benadryl zestoretic online usa no prescription how to get baby to take prevacid best site get sarafem bactrim pills buy doxazosin pharmacy lasix v dyazide rhinocort uk next day delivery minomycin canadian pharmacy nitroglycerin patch generic name zepose 10mg post cycle therapy maxalt bitter lemon quinine pregnancy vigra flyplass 24 hour pharmacy near me uk order allopurinol all rights pharmacy blood pressure medication with least side effects augmentin to buy in england clomid online in usa atorlip-5 discount generic premarin online allegra overnight pharmacy where can i get acai berry donde comprar colchicine where to get hyzaar pct pioglitazone metformin combination yasmin by mail buy kamagra chewable pills online what does hoodia p57 do best place to buy viagra in the uk ampicillin pharmacy online naprosyn 40 mg dose bystolic dosage instructions cheap alphagan sale uk cheapest drug compazine side effects of rimadyl for dogs what is flovent for children propranolol order on web nitroglycerin sublingual tablet dose generic dostinex usa pharmacy pharmacie de garde paris 20 order abilify 10mg online vpxl buy india Purchase amitriptyline 75mg online atorvastatin cost costco overseas pharmacy no prescription cyklokapron what is promethazine plain syrup used for buy serevent inhaler canada what does meclizine look like donde comprar antabuse en venezuela where can i buy zofran bentyl generic dicyclomine viagra for sale no prescription uk lithium sodium and potassium in order of reactivity cheapest motilium tablets uk buy aciclovir 100mg tablets can you order decadron drug saw palmetto for hair loss in women reviews buy bystolic 20 mg what is revatio drugs comprar diabecon original en madrid where do i cialis professional in india zyprexa side effects long term lotrisone no prrescription no prescription accept cheap lipitor viagra super p-force buy viagra sublingual boots where can i buy citalopram mg linen house australia buy online cialis sublingual drug schedule donde comprar xenical roche colombia buy finax online india cefixime without food florida hospital celebration coumadin clinic buying doxazosin from canada no prescription order uk buy diclofenac birth control pills no prescription online glyset in croatia viagra professional now co uk non prescription naprosyn cost of generic wellbutrin without insurance cymbalta fast uk buy alphagan us eye drops generic zestril uk online what is asacol generic name top five drugstore concealers generic cabgolin safe how to use prometrium 100mg capsule amoxil overnight delivery buy buy retino a cream 0 05 mg brand vs generic coumadin comprar isoptin en argentina antivert coupons anything over the counter like flagyl mexican pharmacy no prescription medrol where do i flomax in australia cr2016 lithium battery free shipping femara price india bactrim 200mg+40mg dawkowanie ordering capoten discount coupons for avalide what is albendazole suspension for prescription cheap stromectol view topic lasix water pill for drug test who makes crestor medication ampicillin meningitis dose neonates desyrel 50 mg tablet topical isotretinoin buy low cost retino-a cream 0,05 avapro 300 hct purchase atorlip 20 online purchase blopress kamagra gold suppositories buy buy atarax with no rx zithromax no prescription uk estrace pills for ivf cardizem dose ems cholestoplex drugstore.com purchase alphagan pills buy alli diet pills australia pharmacy famvir dosage too high requisitos visa actos de comercio beconase aq generic 2013 drugs diovan hct sales mylan evista drug in india med-rx urethral catheter s club juniors one step closer gonorrhea resistant to cefixime cefixime uses medication how to get off paxil naturally viagra generico nome viagra super active trusted online drug stores in canada noroxin prices usa furosemide torsemide dose conversion global pharmacy canada cialis what is tadapox drugs buy lady era mg online celexa lexapro weight gain zocor versus generic simvastatin generic from bactrim non prescription mestinon pharmacy best place to buy betapace in canada lariam o malarone india viramune dose plavix online with out prescription tadacip 20 generic buy furosemide in ireland yagara pill shortage maxalt mlt price per pill zyvox dosage children viagra cheapest canada children;s zyrtec discontinued side effects of lisinopril 2.5mg how long does differin take to work for acne citalopram 10 mg depression generic pills for elimite canadian tegretol tablet side effects of losartan 50 mg side effects of doxycycline 100mg for acne pink+pill+for+women+viagra levitra tablets used for finax next day buy arava online no prescription us acheter phenergan pas cher cheapest benicar hct metformin paypal where to buy accutane australia isotretinoin is there a generic version of levitra raloxifene hydrochloride usp fda approves daily cialis doses finasteride 5mg tablets generic proscar synthroid doses available online viagra from canada alesse generic recall synthroid online in canada low cost xeloda get carbozyne toronto discount code for voveran eldepryl purchase in canada no prescription acai drug class safe place order arava canadian pharmacy 24hr.com best overnight pharmacies normal dose of trazodone for insomnia generic synthroid uk canada pharmacies online that sell cephalexin augmentin online buy antibiotics online no prescription purim overnight pharmacy nitroglycerin tablets non-prescription synthroid discount card can i get high on aleve pharmacy technician exam review online plavix side effects bleeding buy tadifilas flovent ordering online pharmacy innopran xl australia price how to buy cialis in mexico reglan 20mg tab safe dose of zofran for pregnant women to buy forzest cheap diflucan free delivery cardizem woldwide shipping nizoral shampoo singapore where to buy feldene not generic viagra for women problems aspirin tablets on line to buy maximum dose of wellbutrin per day how much does seroquel cost with insurance buy albuterol from mexico lozol over the couter hydromorphone 2mg pill generic acivir pills paypal buy generic tetracycline including toprol xl online price buy cipro online forum donde comprar risperdal order levaquin from canada without prescription how much nolvadex 40mg serophene drugstore.com discount skelaxin acai berry diet buy online propranolol precio en mexico what does ginseng tea taste like where can i buy erythromycin online uk natural pain meds for cats cost comparison generic phenergan mg lasuna brand positioning zenegra generic viagra side effects prednisone 20mg tablet inderal tablets 10mg side effects where to buy amantadine voltaren discounter allegra over the counter dosage fexofenadine cialis v viagra review what is levothyroxine taken for what is zoloft supposed to do zithromax prices generic depo provera price clonidine pills used order clomid online cheap crestor 40 mg 28 film tablet brand cialis pharmacy store where can i get acyclovir over the counter online pharmacy no prescription needed actos how much is generic seroquel what does synthroid do for hypothyroidism legitimate canadian pharmacy online atrovent drugs for sale antabuse refills Purchase kamagra 100mg online buy albendazole pills in the india viagra original si is haldol discontinued in the us viagra jelly refills can you buy viagra in amsterdam walmart pharmacy refill prescription buy levitra professional online uk no prescription levoxyl and prednisone drug interactions risperdal no prescription needed cialis jelly on the internet amaryl glimepiride price cialis soft generic usa lotrisone shop net promethazine over the counter substitute saturday delivery combivent order order elimite online with visa xalatan price in india yasmine bleeth what is she doing now diflucan shortage maximum dose paxil per day gout attack while taking allopurinol micardis weight gain motrin suspension 20 mg purchase betapace cheap sildenafil como se usa buy pct steroids levitra delivered to your home etodolac ordering no prescription online mentax india online buy aldactone without discount valtrex how much will viagra sublingual cost buy imitrex cheap what is the usual dosage of prednisone for poison ivy actos drugs for sale canadian robaxin buy tamoxifen online amazon rumalaya liniment for men in usa buy adalat online overnight delivery side effects of serevent diskus buy doxazosin next day over the counter acai seroquel without a prescription from canada can buy promethazine codeine syrup over counter buying generic viagra using paypal albuterol tablets dosage buy procardia online without a prescription can u buy viagra in india viagra paid by paypal account deltasone without insurance amitriptyline pills com rosuvastatin brand order what does generic avapro look like cialis 5 mg daily best place to buy entocort what is the drug motilium used for chloromycetin women buy clonidine tablets 40mg breakout right after accutane thyroid medication not working symptoms is generic finasteride the same as propecia baclofen prices walgreens actos from canada norvasc dosage forms acquistare arimidex in italia ordering soft tabs cialis tadalafil xenical mg mexico us pharmacies online that sell plavix where to buy pariet current price eurax pharmacy has best price estrace prevacid solutab over the counter generic viagra me uk kamagra dramamine price how to buy yasmin in uk cuanto vale el viagra en el salvador aciclovir generic release date over counter vasodilan can you buy lotrisone drugs pharmacy online pharmacy no prescription needed snovitra super power no prescription aldactone sale bentyl capsules 10mg purchase himcocid lilly cialis uk american express canada costco cash back what is prednisolone for cough menosan limited india online pharmacy cialis generic atrovent over the counter tetracycline usa cvs prices bactrim maximum dosage avodart buy without a subscription how to get retin-a 0,05 in australia brand name effexor xr online to buy decadron drugs prescription can you buy calcium carbonate over the counter side effects of depakote 500 mg zocor medicine side effects best place to buy femara in usa get synthroid toronto inderal 10mg performance anxiety serophene reviews and dosage western drug wellbutrin sr rabeprazole sodium msds diflucan overnight lamisil over the counter cream buy diamox us prescription buy clonidine with e check 100mg viagra vs 50 mg buy diflucan online cheap without rx what is the best medication for anxiety in children retin-a ge generic 2013 drugs maxalt migraine side effects herbal viagra pills cheapest place to buy trental isoptin generic name order 3 trial erection packs cialis female viagra pills pink pill crestor 10 mg retail price brand viagra woldwide shipping bactrim for men in usa naltrexone information sheet buying adalat for dogs list of tesco stores selling hyaluronic acid get minomycin las vegas indian version of viagra penegra protonix 40 mg twice daily renagel tablets 1600 mg mobic generic meloxicam buy amaryl cheap generic drug for valtrex cleocin gel for sale philippines top 10 online fluoxetine sites buy viagra plus inhaler canada there generic drug pulmicort can you buy cefadroxil over the counter in germany diakof phone orders obagi tretinoin cream usp 0.1 - 20g/0.68oz alli where can i buy what does promethazine hydrochloride do risperdal medicine buy elavil 200 water pills lose weight yahoo answers comprar aciclovir portugal zithromax maximum dosage best price for real liv 52 lasuna price india buy cabgolin online cheap what is the medication diflucan for best online pharmacy generic diltiazem is mail order erythromycin safe cheapest cephalexin florinef order by phone list of tesco stores selling prevacid how to buy benemid nymphomax no prescription compare prices sominex drug oversea where can i buy pletal in uk can i get kytril canadian alliance terminals richmond bc order endep online in usa seroquel on line purchase buy bupropion sr where can i buy antivert in canada what is reglan used to treat in dogs pharmacy has best price pletal pariet over the counter drugs protonix and plavix interaction flagyl er 10 mg why is there a shortage of actos carbozyne prescription coupon can we buy birth control pills over the counter pletal 100 mg uses cozaar ordering online pharmacy is allegra otc in canada desyrel 100 mg kullananlar maximum paroxetine dosage mexican liposafe clindamycin pregnancy safety where to buy proventil liquid femara uk cialis originale acquisto on line what are levaquin pills used for digoxin medication dogs glyset pharmacy
Consulting Core Services
On-Site Training

GCA can orient the course to any  number of topics but typical ones have included:

  • Basics of the Federal Acquisition Regulation
  • FAR Cost Principles
  • Cost Accounting Standards
  • Working with DCAA
Sample Download

Click to download and view a sample of a recent issue of the GCA REPORT.
Click to download and view  a sample of a recent issue of the GCA DIGEST.

 

Contact Us

Don't hesitate to contact us if you have any questions, comments, suggestions, or problems with registration.

Phone: 1-925-362-0712

Fax: 925-362-0806

Email GCA

Subscriber Login

Path: Consulting Services arrow Report & Digest arrow GCA Digest Articles arrow GCA Digest 1998 arrow Alternatives for the Accounting Treatment of Fringe Benefits

Alternatives for the Accounting Treatment of Fringe Benefits

(Editor’s Note. The firm utilizing only full time employees who are paid generous fringe benefits are becoming the exception rather than the rule. The tough competitive environment of the government market are requiring increasing usage of mixed employment/contract relationships where, for example, temporary and/or offsite employees receiving lower fringe benefits, requiring lower facility and support costs, etc provide opportunities to offer the government lower prices based on lower indirect costs. Our consulting work helping organizations change their direct and indirect rate structure leads us to the unmistakable conclusion that each firm is different and requires a carefully designed approach. We have found the following article in the August CP&A Report by Darrell Oyer, a long time Government contracts consultant and principle of the Darrell J. Oyer & Company, intriguing for illustrating some alternative approaches.)

Fringe benefits costs as a percentage of direct labor has increased substantially in the last ten years. New employment arrangements altering the composition of the workforce has also caused potential variations in indirect cost rates. A brief review of FAR and CAS allocation rules precede a discussion of alternative treatment of fringe benefit costs.

Definition of Fringe Benefits

Fringe benefits are allowances and services provided by a contractor to its employees as compensation in addition to regular wages and salaries. They generally include costs of paid absences for vacations, sick leave, holidays and military leave, employee insurance and supplemental unemployment benefit tax. The US Chamber of Commerce adds (1) legally required payments such as employee FICA taxes (2) retirement and savings plan payments, profit sharing, stock bonuses, Employee Stock Option Plans and defined-benefit and defined contribution pension plans (3) life insurance and death benefit payments (4) medical and medically related payments (5) paid rest periods and (6) miscellaneous benefits such as discount on company products and services, education expense, child care and employee meals.

Allowability

FAR 31.205-6(m) makes the costs of fringe benefits generally allowable to the extent they are reasonable, required by law, employee-employer agreements or are established policy of the contractor. Costs of several types of fringe benefits are subject to separate, detailed allowability criteria (e.g. employee rebate and discount (unallowable), hours and incentive compensation (allowable subject to specified purpose and documentation), pension plans (allowable if computed according to CAS 412 and 413)).

Allocability

FAR 31.201-4 provides general guidance to cost allocations: "a cost is allocable if it is assignable or chargeable to one or more cost objectives on the basis of relative benefits received or other equitable relationship". Since it is difficult to identify fringe benefit costs to a specific contract the allocation criterion is whether a fringe expense benefits both the contract and other work and can be distributed to them in reasonable proportion to the benefits received. FAR 31.203 refines guidelines on allocating indirect costs by stipulating "homogeneous pools" of costs that can be allocated to separate contracts on a similar base should be accumulated while excessive cost grouping may be avoided if substantially similar results are achieved.

The allocation rules provide a wide range of choices for pooling and allocating fringe benefits. The guidance indicates contractors should consider whether the cost pool or pools are homogeneous. If fringe benefits vary substantially between full time and say, less than full time or field personnel, separate fringe pools might be necessary to achieve homogeneous grouping. FAR 31.203(b), on the other hand, stresses it is not necessary to proliferate pools to achieve perfect cost allocation.

Allocation Base

A direct labor dollar base is the usual choice for allocating fringe benefit costs and certainly the preferred choice of government auditors. A different allocation base (e.g. labor hours) may be justified when some fringe benefit costs vary by number of employees (e.g. fixed medical cost) or salary level (e.g. pension). Two separate pools with different bases are usually frowned upon for providing excess complexity with little added benefit.

Cost Pool Alternatives

When a company has primarily full time employees there are various methods of pooling fringe benefits that can yield very different rates and pose various levels of complexity. Fringe benefit costs are usually included as (1) on of many cost elements in various overhead and/or G&A pools or (2) in various separate fringe benefit pools.

Inclusion in the Indirect Cost Pool. Frequently, fringe benefit costs are accumulated with other indirect costs in an appropriate pool such as manufacturing overhead, engineering overhead or general and administrative (G&A). The fringe benefits for both direct and indirect labor are usually included.

The primary benefit of this approach is its simplicity. Lumping all indirect costs including fringe benefits into one or two pools is quite easy. There are two major disadvantages to this approach: (1) fringe benefit costs are not easily identifiable and hence easily monitored and controlled and (2) a higher indirect cost rate results in contrast to including fringe benefits and or other indirect costs in separate pools. For example, an indirect rate of 138% may be viewed more unfavorably than a 100% overhead rate and a 38% fringe benefit rate. As an added incentive, an even lower overhead rate can be made to appear if "direct labor costs" are defined as direct labor dollars plus applied fringe benefit costs.

Allocation of Separate Fringe Cost Pool. A contractor may decide to establish a separate fringe benefit pool to focus management attention of this important cost, to lower indirect cost rates or achieve more precision in its cost allocation methods. Once this decision is made, the contractor must then decide which costs are included in the fringe benefit pool and which costs are in the base.

The discussion below assumes two categories of labor: direct employees who work both direct and indirect functions and indirect employees who work only indirect functions.

Total Fringe Benefits (for direct and indirect labor) with a Direct Labor Base of Direct Employees. If all fringe benefits are in the pool and divided by only direct labor, this approach will yield a high fringe benefits rate because the numerator (total benefits for all employees) is divided by a lower denominator (direct labor only).

Fringe Benefits Costs for Direct Labor Only with a Direct Labor Base of Direct Employees. The lower numerator (fringe benefits for only direct labor) divided over the direct labor base will tend to lower the fringe benefit rate. One problem of this approach is how to handle the fringe benefits of direct labor employees when they perform indirect rate functions (e.g. attending training, idle time).

Fringe Benefits Costs for Direct Labor Only with a Direct Labor Plus Indirect Labor of Direct Employees. Calculate separate fringe benefit rates for direct and indirect employees. When direct employees work directly their fringe benefits are in effect charged to the job worked while when charging indirect, their fringe benefits are charged to an overhead pool like the indirect employees. The advantage of greater precision and a lower fringe benefit is offset against more detailed recordkeeping.

Allocation Through Intermediate Cost Pool. Combine all fringe benefits for all employees in one intermediate cost pool and allocate them on a base of total labor dollars of both direct and indirect employees. Fringe benefit costs are then, in turn, charged either to cost objectives for direct labor or other indirect cost pools. This results in a lower fringe benefit rate and is easy to use but can cause some cost distortion if some employees receive significantly greater salaries and greater fringe benefits (e.g. executives). The distortion can be minimized if fringe benefit rates are similar for all employees or the dollar differences are minimal.

Multiple Fringe Benefit Cost Pools By Employee Category

The increased use of less than full-time employees has created a need for more sophisticated accounting. The use of these employees has created real cost savings (e.g. lower fringe benefits, less support, reductions in idle time disguised as other activities) and contractors need to translate these savings into lower indirect rates for pricing purposes. Full time employees may receive all fringe benefits such as health insurance, vacation, and statutory payroll taxes, part time employees may receive limited fringe benefits such as vacation and statutory payroll taxes while temporary employees may receive only statutory taxes.

One solution for accounting for these varied fringe benefits is to account for them in layers or tiers. As the Table 1 below indicates, the first fringe benefits pool or tier consists of statutory fringe benefits that all employees receive. The second fringe benefit tier could consist of those benefits available to part time and full time employees while the third tier consists of those benefits received only by full time employees. Table 2 illustrates the resulting fringe benefit rate for each class of employee. Contractors can bid temporary employees at 6.93%, part-time employees at 19.43% and full time employees at the full fringe benefit rate of 37.75%.

Multiple fringe benefit pools can also be useful if benefits vary for any reason between different organizational units or facilities. For example, an organization with multistate locations where state employment taxes or different union agreements may require establishing multiple fringe benefit cost pools.

(Editor’s Note. Contractors fully covered by CAS should be aware that changes to their methods or techniques of allocating fringe benefits will likely be considered a change to an accounting practice requiring altering the disclosure statement and possibly triggering the need for a cost impact proposal and negotiating a price adjustments on CAS covered contracts. On the other hand, we have seen instances of a different treatment of fringe benefits by new categories of employees considered as an adoption of a new accounting practice, averting the claim of a change to an old practice. This discussion is beyond the scope of this article and competent CAS experts should be consulted.)

{TAG_FORM_TITLE}

To discuss your needs, contact Bill Lennett, Principal, at 1-925-362-0712 or email him at This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it .

*
 
*
 
*
 
 
*
 
 

 
GCA Subscription
REPORT FEATURES
  • New Developments-Rule Changes, New Guidelines, Court Decisions
  • Feature article for Small/New Contractors
  • Practical Q&A Sections

Download & View Sample


DIGEST FEATURES
  • Experts' Discussion of "HOT" Contracting Issues
  • Analyzing a Cost Principle or Cost Accounting Standard
  • Pricing Strategies
  • Case Studies on Challenges to Government Findings

Download & View Sample


SUBSCRIBER BENEFITS
  • Free use of our "Ask the Experts" panel where subscribers can submit questions to or chat with our network of eminent consultants and attorneys.
  • Electronic access to all prior newsletters through 2000. We provide state-of-the-art word search Word and linked electronic index to all articles.
  • Mailed hard copies and electronic versions will provide timely access to all newsletters.

 Learn More

 Subscribe