side effects of atenolol 50 mg cafergot cheap us pharmacy order diclofenac sodium pharmacy brand nizagara buy buying atorlip-5 revatio wiki mentat ds syrup sold over counter cheapest drug levaquin eurax online uk how much does clonidine cost on the street how to purchase suhagra is it safe to buy prescription drugs in mexico finpecia from united pharmacy cialis levitra pas cher acai delivery morumbi erythromycin better than amoxicillin diflucan online order discount viagra australia lowest cost pharmacy canada cialis suprax online ordering is generic himplasia available in usa proscar without insurance clozaril lowest price online buy levitra plus online atarax dose dogs morning after pill cost asda over the counter propecia how much is neurontin without insurance buspar online pharmacies with out prescription where to buy nolvadex online uk cialis jelly drugs for sale clonidine 40 mg dose levitra professional usa sale research grade endep classification of illegal drugs uk buy elimite bulk allopurinol 300 mg prices elimite purchase in canada no prescription where did wu zetian die cost of crestor at cvs where aleve fluticasone and salmeterol advair diskus is an appropriate treatment for what generic trazodone uk paypal asacol brands india isoptin cheap kamagra from indonesia malegra dxt order by phone generic from effexor xr where to get viagra in london generic tinidazole cost micronase drug schedule zoloft during pregnancy lawsuit antivert generic for s and m cafe cheap homes for sale in alliance ohio overseas viagra generic pills for fertomid college of medicine and allied health sciences university of sierra leone resultsrx buy online trileptal generic problems 100 percent hoodia diet pills suprax express canada midamor reviews diabecon online cheap hydrochlorothiazide dosage for dogs what kind of acne does differin treat zyvox sales buy drugs lopressor generic reviews ordering cialis super active cheapest price premarin cheapest best price for real tinidazole v-gel without insurance amaryllis order online pletal tablets for sale asacol hd 800mg lasix 40 mg tablets for dogs is famvir available over the counter cytoxan tablets on line to buy antivert uk online lanoxin now buy cheap seroquel xr online amantadine cost cost of requip xl 2mg fastest cabgolin uk delivery buy dapoxetine mexican pharmacies kamagra oral jelly mit paypal kaufen wellbutrin sr tablets purchase on line accutane price generic fincar buy canada buy viagra usa online bestrxonlinepharmacy online prescription viagra online usa online pharmacy fda approved buy finax 40 buy cheap pfizer viagra online homeopathy medicine lower back pain cheap xenical online australia prednisolone 5mg 1000 toprol xl without prescription miami aciclovir fast uk prednisone to buy uk prescription wockhardt usa lisinopril side effects taking 100mg clomid medrol prices cvs best generic exelon sites buy levitra plus mg online buy accutane online no prescription fast delivery buy tretinoin 0,025 boots pharmacy order suhagra online no prescription with a visa purchase diflucan mg is there a cvs pharmacy in canada zithromax is a member of what category of drugs gia thuoc ciprobay 500mg where to minomycin casodex without a prescription new viagra competitor motrin coupons 2011 best drugs for genital herpes cheap amantadine buy billig voltaren online kaufen buy methotrexate mexican pharmacies sumycin medicine canada pharmacy online phentermine rxcanadian mall cheap cialis professional sale uk generic cialis mens health non generic clonidine pills doctor buying ginseng in seoul where can i buy actonel in canada generic name for nitroglycerin liv 52 australian customs tricor medication where to buy can youtube buy levitra professional in ireland cialis cheap propecia 1mg online pariet costo depo medrol injection rxlist detrol side effects elderly buy keflex pills do i need a prescription for dramamine buy provera online no prescription online pharmacy uk voltaren does bactrim pills look like very cheap benemid medrol dose pack patient instructions buy dostinex in singapore is there a generic medication for strattera zovirax phone orders buy midamor without a script tinidazole side effects buying effexor xr without a prescription sarafem to buy in australia celexa 40 mg canada purchase tretinoin online generic plan b pill cvs piroxicam topical mexico decadron flagyl 400mg and alcohol worldwide pharmacy aricept viagra and cialis taken together ordering zovirax ointment protonix coupons rebates decadron dose pack mg online pharmacy testosterone enanthate side effects of triamterene w hctz generic tretinoin cream 0.1 mail order provera propranolol and alcohol use buy generic elocon there generic tegretol prevacid from colic buy levitra super active online from usa imitrex online cheap depakote no rx daily cialis coupons cheap houses to buy liverpool where to buy diclofenac gel to buy claritin drugstore code 20 off omeprazole 20 mg price can you buy prilosec otc over the counter indian generics online lozol safe prednisone dosage for dogs cheap car insurance for young women can i buy antibiotics online uk cheap stephen jackson stats football detrol australia price skip hop zoo pack canada prazosin from usa how to buy remeron in london buy brand cialis tablets usa pcos late ovulation on clomid terramycin mg price propecia prescription online wellbutrin pill canadian is viagra sold over the counter in the u s zofran italiano fosamax plus d price glucotrol xl tablet sale ceftin where to purchase florida myambutol price of abortion pills in india order feldene lowest price comprar cialis online opiniones allopurinol alternatives natural nizoral shampoo brand names nexium prices cvs what is proventil tablets proventil dosage forms best drugstore foundation 2012 yahoo atorlip-20 price buy cytoxan bulk what does phenergan tablets treat zofran generic available generic oxytrol safe cheap clomid uk is antabuse over the counter shipping best generic viagra in uk cost of differin gel without insurance purchase zoloft in mexico canada ciprodex prescription omifin clomifeno tabletas 50 mg cheapest serophene tablets uk pravachol without prescription que es mambo 36 zyrtec woldwide shipping metformin generic 2013 drugs buy propecia online nz lexapro sales 2009 buy tofranil online pharmacy accutane cystic acne reviews slimming tablets with speed in them order wellbutrin sr medication by mail effexor xr and alcohol cravings cost of floxin otic brand name cialis no prrescription buy generic tadacip online mexican pharmacy no prescription roxithromycin canadian alliance of dance artists professional association prednisolone shop net can you get rechargeable lithium batteries malegra fxt canada head office information on doxycycline 100mg tablets sale serophene buy bentyl from canada motrin comprare canadian pharmacy elavil do you gain weight taking crestor kamagra made in india erythromycin stearate alcohol mexican pharmacy no prescription rumalaya forte half price elimite prometrium suppliers overseas tinidazole weight gain phexin buy canada arava order by phone 100mg doxycycline tablets best online pharmacy generic artane get precose las vegas venlor next day generic pyridium cost beconase aq order canada buy alli visa synthroid buy online us como comprar olanzapine buy crestor online with mastercard daily dosage of cialis is it safe to take generic lexapro where did amaryllis originate propecia price increase online finpecia purchase valtrex from usa what does abilify do to your body where to buy toprol xl drugs online cialis jelly daily use reviews donde comprar raiz de ginseng en chile anafranil suppositories buy fastest mentax uk delivery keflex ordering online pharmacy no prescription rogaine 2 buy reglan online overnight floxin order canada order alligator gar approved amitriptyline sleep apnea no prescription antidepressants best online pharmacy buy accutane what does erexor bupropion 150 mg price glucotrol xl 10mg tablet cipro in italia best place to buy urispas renagel reviews for men acivir pills mg buy tetracycline uk no prescription himalaya confido tablets 60 viagra soft mexico pharmacy is there a generic brand for differin paxil tablets dose best site for differin over the counter equivalent to protonix buy liv with e check buy differin low cheap price home chlamydia test effexor xr free shipping short term high dose prednisone side effects skelaxin generic available buy genuine artane uk propranolol cheap purchase levaquin on line in usa generic cialis kopen cheap viagra sale uk actonel ordering no prescription comprar aspirin original buy deltasone new zealand online kamagra 100mg oral jelly side effects blue pill review pyridium by mail propranolol from mexico can order l-tryptophan canada clomid buy on line aleve dose strength viagra sublingual for sale order cialis canada 18 gbp to eur what does cefixime look like fungsi obat metronidazole para que son las pastillas de cialis atrovent online norvasc reviews for men buy finpecia paypal accepted digoxin medline india himcocid no prescription canada over counter allegra d equivalent kwikmed coupon free shipping buy generic rumalaya lipitor prescription cost combivent for discount order non generic prometrium aciclovir comprimidos 400 mg dosis what is the generic form of flomax safe buy serevent online order generic hyaluronic acid lowest priced synthroid buy brand advair diskus without rx midamor shortage 2012 maxalt lingua 10mg schwangerschaft dove comprare cialis generico on line where to buy finpecia uk discount adalat sony tv reviews purchase generic benadryl to buy fluoxetine buy vantin online overnight delivery where doo amaryllis come from albenza drugs online purchases suppliers of asacol in us haldol druppels of tabletten minocycline supplier in uk phone in order for menosan order nolvadex pill prevacid to buy in england buy revia patch where can i buy feldene order diclofenac potassium advair diskus shortage what is amlodipine used for prilosec otc for sale prednisone withdrawal joint pain canadian pharmacy benemid cefixime brand names in india keppra 100mg/ml cheap robaxin mg promethazine tired next day can u buy birth control pills online prednisone side effects uk buy cefixime 5 ingredients in viagra pro what is cialis soft luvox without a perscription light blue oval pill watson 540 naprosyn no prescription canada resources for lexapro torsemide tablets for sale over the counter accutane for acne what is avodart dutasteride can buy procardia online ortho tri-cyclen buy online ireland cymbalta lawsuit 2010 what does the drug femara do what is the brand name for furosemide uk order aleve 120 mg buy yasmin online from canada pulmicort without a prescription best price for real dipyridamole alli medication buy common blood pressure medication uk non prescription cymbalta side effects of tamoxifen in men inderal tablets uk sinequan 10 mg valtrex retailer original shuddha guggulu online buy zovirax eye ointment how to take care of a calandiva plant order zovirax cream diabecon online in usa where do i doxycycline in mexico how much is prometrium tablets finasteride over the counter uk depakote pharmacy buy cialis jelly inhaler canada voveran sr online overnight how to buy skelaxin in london drugs similar to aciphex generic female viagra overnite shipping cialis cyprus what kind of medication is synthroid mail-order cafergot what is cardizem la para que se usa toradol celexa on the internet toprol xl tablets side effects hytrin generic cheap costs purchasing paxil online strattera for men sale in uk allegra versace 2012 hoodia to buy in australia buy drugs online using tor dilantin levels monitoring long does take nizoral pills work synthroid vs levothyroxine singulair generic name bactrim compuesto sustancia activa cheap ampicillin uk atorlip-20 to buy from europe nizagara for sale philippines para que se usa el xeloda amaryl women buy indocin to buy in england genuine astelin 100mg what is metformin for infertility purchase antabuse on line in mexico cialis soft no prescription canada web prescriptions webprescriptions medescribe co uk normal cozaar dose mail order bactrim do hoodia tablets work minomycin with paypal payment what is hydrochlorothiazide pills used for what does the name allegra mean buy brahmi boots where to purchase nizoral cream forum baclofene aubes buy hyaluronic acid pills long term usage of evista no prescription indian pharmacy buy tramadol cod delivery terramycin online best price aristocort buy adalat 30 mg angina buy diflucan singapore buy carbozyne usa where to get minipress pct buy malegra dxt online from usa ordering bactrim on line where can you buy viagra prescription alphagan pas cher diclofenac epolamine topical patch generic post cycle therapy serophene buy gasex bulk genuine alli best site to buy viagra professional buying aspirin best place buy toradol pct buy zantac canada ortho tri cyclen online without prescription pariet drug store online haldol cheap terramycin order canada lowest priced ventolin erythromycin medication drug pyridium 100 mg dosis best drugstore liquid foundation for acne prone skin toprol xl with american express order duetact overnight bystolic without prescription miami kwikmed online coupon comprar propecia mexico df is generic viagra from india safe vigrashop24h.com buy maxalt from canada levitra plus pharmacies urispas without prescription where can i get elocon cream what does yasmin mean in persian viagra deaths blindness orlistat for cheap buy cialis soft in usa post cycle therapy grifulvin v severe anxiety in children cheapest prednisolone to buy generic effexor xr in us prograf sold over counter fluconazole dose for thrush combivent udv side effects buy revatio us urispas mg buy micronase weight gain does tamoxifen cause weight gain 2010 propecia from india online is citalopram prescription only cymbalta overnight pharmacy +buy cafergot no perscription donde venden pastillas alli mexico cheapest cleocin gel to buy buy indocin india purchasing luvox online uk arimidex cost cytotec best price zithromax pharmacies cefixime online from usa best online pharmacy generic buspar nhs viagra prescriptions order snovitra super power actonel prices walmart dapoxetine for sale philippines can i get high off antivert premarin discontinued very cheap sumycin aciphex dosage administration
Consulting Core Services
On-Site Training

GCA can orient the course to any  number of topics but typical ones have included:

  • Basics of the Federal Acquisition Regulation
  • FAR Cost Principles
  • Cost Accounting Standards
  • Working with DCAA
Contact Us

Don't hesitate to contact us if you have any questions, comments, suggestions, or problems with registration.

Phone: 1-925-362-0712

Fax: 925-362-0806

Email GCA

Subscriber Login

Path: Consulting Services arrow Report & Digest arrow GCA Digest Articles arrow GCA Digest 1998 arrow Alternatives for the Accounting Treatment of Fringe Benefits

Alternatives for the Accounting Treatment of Fringe Benefits

(Editor’s Note. The firm utilizing only full time employees who are paid generous fringe benefits are becoming the exception rather than the rule. The tough competitive environment of the government market are requiring increasing usage of mixed employment/contract relationships where, for example, temporary and/or offsite employees receiving lower fringe benefits, requiring lower facility and support costs, etc provide opportunities to offer the government lower prices based on lower indirect costs. Our consulting work helping organizations change their direct and indirect rate structure leads us to the unmistakable conclusion that each firm is different and requires a carefully designed approach. We have found the following article in the August CP&A Report by Darrell Oyer, a long time Government contracts consultant and principle of the Darrell J. Oyer & Company, intriguing for illustrating some alternative approaches.)

Fringe benefits costs as a percentage of direct labor has increased substantially in the last ten years. New employment arrangements altering the composition of the workforce has also caused potential variations in indirect cost rates. A brief review of FAR and CAS allocation rules precede a discussion of alternative treatment of fringe benefit costs.

Definition of Fringe Benefits

Fringe benefits are allowances and services provided by a contractor to its employees as compensation in addition to regular wages and salaries. They generally include costs of paid absences for vacations, sick leave, holidays and military leave, employee insurance and supplemental unemployment benefit tax. The US Chamber of Commerce adds (1) legally required payments such as employee FICA taxes (2) retirement and savings plan payments, profit sharing, stock bonuses, Employee Stock Option Plans and defined-benefit and defined contribution pension plans (3) life insurance and death benefit payments (4) medical and medically related payments (5) paid rest periods and (6) miscellaneous benefits such as discount on company products and services, education expense, child care and employee meals.

Allowability

FAR 31.205-6(m) makes the costs of fringe benefits generally allowable to the extent they are reasonable, required by law, employee-employer agreements or are established policy of the contractor. Costs of several types of fringe benefits are subject to separate, detailed allowability criteria (e.g. employee rebate and discount (unallowable), hours and incentive compensation (allowable subject to specified purpose and documentation), pension plans (allowable if computed according to CAS 412 and 413)).

Allocability

FAR 31.201-4 provides general guidance to cost allocations: "a cost is allocable if it is assignable or chargeable to one or more cost objectives on the basis of relative benefits received or other equitable relationship". Since it is difficult to identify fringe benefit costs to a specific contract the allocation criterion is whether a fringe expense benefits both the contract and other work and can be distributed to them in reasonable proportion to the benefits received. FAR 31.203 refines guidelines on allocating indirect costs by stipulating "homogeneous pools" of costs that can be allocated to separate contracts on a similar base should be accumulated while excessive cost grouping may be avoided if substantially similar results are achieved.

The allocation rules provide a wide range of choices for pooling and allocating fringe benefits. The guidance indicates contractors should consider whether the cost pool or pools are homogeneous. If fringe benefits vary substantially between full time and say, less than full time or field personnel, separate fringe pools might be necessary to achieve homogeneous grouping. FAR 31.203(b), on the other hand, stresses it is not necessary to proliferate pools to achieve perfect cost allocation.

Allocation Base

A direct labor dollar base is the usual choice for allocating fringe benefit costs and certainly the preferred choice of government auditors. A different allocation base (e.g. labor hours) may be justified when some fringe benefit costs vary by number of employees (e.g. fixed medical cost) or salary level (e.g. pension). Two separate pools with different bases are usually frowned upon for providing excess complexity with little added benefit.

Cost Pool Alternatives

When a company has primarily full time employees there are various methods of pooling fringe benefits that can yield very different rates and pose various levels of complexity. Fringe benefit costs are usually included as (1) on of many cost elements in various overhead and/or G&A pools or (2) in various separate fringe benefit pools.

Inclusion in the Indirect Cost Pool. Frequently, fringe benefit costs are accumulated with other indirect costs in an appropriate pool such as manufacturing overhead, engineering overhead or general and administrative (G&A). The fringe benefits for both direct and indirect labor are usually included.

The primary benefit of this approach is its simplicity. Lumping all indirect costs including fringe benefits into one or two pools is quite easy. There are two major disadvantages to this approach: (1) fringe benefit costs are not easily identifiable and hence easily monitored and controlled and (2) a higher indirect cost rate results in contrast to including fringe benefits and or other indirect costs in separate pools. For example, an indirect rate of 138% may be viewed more unfavorably than a 100% overhead rate and a 38% fringe benefit rate. As an added incentive, an even lower overhead rate can be made to appear if "direct labor costs" are defined as direct labor dollars plus applied fringe benefit costs.

Allocation of Separate Fringe Cost Pool. A contractor may decide to establish a separate fringe benefit pool to focus management attention of this important cost, to lower indirect cost rates or achieve more precision in its cost allocation methods. Once this decision is made, the contractor must then decide which costs are included in the fringe benefit pool and which costs are in the base.

The discussion below assumes two categories of labor: direct employees who work both direct and indirect functions and indirect employees who work only indirect functions.

Total Fringe Benefits (for direct and indirect labor) with a Direct Labor Base of Direct Employees. If all fringe benefits are in the pool and divided by only direct labor, this approach will yield a high fringe benefits rate because the numerator (total benefits for all employees) is divided by a lower denominator (direct labor only).

Fringe Benefits Costs for Direct Labor Only with a Direct Labor Base of Direct Employees. The lower numerator (fringe benefits for only direct labor) divided over the direct labor base will tend to lower the fringe benefit rate. One problem of this approach is how to handle the fringe benefits of direct labor employees when they perform indirect rate functions (e.g. attending training, idle time).

Fringe Benefits Costs for Direct Labor Only with a Direct Labor Plus Indirect Labor of Direct Employees. Calculate separate fringe benefit rates for direct and indirect employees. When direct employees work directly their fringe benefits are in effect charged to the job worked while when charging indirect, their fringe benefits are charged to an overhead pool like the indirect employees. The advantage of greater precision and a lower fringe benefit is offset against more detailed recordkeeping.

Allocation Through Intermediate Cost Pool. Combine all fringe benefits for all employees in one intermediate cost pool and allocate them on a base of total labor dollars of both direct and indirect employees. Fringe benefit costs are then, in turn, charged either to cost objectives for direct labor or other indirect cost pools. This results in a lower fringe benefit rate and is easy to use but can cause some cost distortion if some employees receive significantly greater salaries and greater fringe benefits (e.g. executives). The distortion can be minimized if fringe benefit rates are similar for all employees or the dollar differences are minimal.

Multiple Fringe Benefit Cost Pools By Employee Category

The increased use of less than full-time employees has created a need for more sophisticated accounting. The use of these employees has created real cost savings (e.g. lower fringe benefits, less support, reductions in idle time disguised as other activities) and contractors need to translate these savings into lower indirect rates for pricing purposes. Full time employees may receive all fringe benefits such as health insurance, vacation, and statutory payroll taxes, part time employees may receive limited fringe benefits such as vacation and statutory payroll taxes while temporary employees may receive only statutory taxes.

One solution for accounting for these varied fringe benefits is to account for them in layers or tiers. As the Table 1 below indicates, the first fringe benefits pool or tier consists of statutory fringe benefits that all employees receive. The second fringe benefit tier could consist of those benefits available to part time and full time employees while the third tier consists of those benefits received only by full time employees. Table 2 illustrates the resulting fringe benefit rate for each class of employee. Contractors can bid temporary employees at 6.93%, part-time employees at 19.43% and full time employees at the full fringe benefit rate of 37.75%.

Multiple fringe benefit pools can also be useful if benefits vary for any reason between different organizational units or facilities. For example, an organization with multistate locations where state employment taxes or different union agreements may require establishing multiple fringe benefit cost pools.

(Editor’s Note. Contractors fully covered by CAS should be aware that changes to their methods or techniques of allocating fringe benefits will likely be considered a change to an accounting practice requiring altering the disclosure statement and possibly triggering the need for a cost impact proposal and negotiating a price adjustments on CAS covered contracts. On the other hand, we have seen instances of a different treatment of fringe benefits by new categories of employees considered as an adoption of a new accounting practice, averting the claim of a change to an old practice. This discussion is beyond the scope of this article and competent CAS experts should be consulted.)

{TAG_FORM_TITLE}

To discuss your needs, contact Bill Lennett, Principal, at 1-925-362-0712 or email him at This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it .

*
 
*
 
*
 
 
*
 
 

 
GCA Subscription
REPORT FEATURES
  • New Developments-Rule Changes, New Guidelines, Court Decisions
  • Feature article for Small/New Contractors
  • Practical Q&A Sections

Download & View Sample


DIGEST FEATURES
  • Experts' Discussion of "HOT" Contracting Issues
  • Analyzing a Cost Principle or Cost Accounting Standard
  • Pricing Strategies
  • Case Studies on Challenges to Government Findings

Download & View Sample


SUBSCRIBER BENEFITS
  • Free use of our "Ask the Experts" panel where subscribers can submit questions to or chat with our network of eminent consultants and attorneys.
  • Electronic access to all prior newsletters through 2000. We provide state-of-the-art word search Word and linked electronic index to all articles.
  • Mailed hard copies and electronic versions will provide timely access to all newsletters.

 Learn More

 Subscribe