atepros drug interaction buy proscar online farmacy on line 100 mg viagra xenical online metrogel 0.75 price canadian pharmacies nexium neurontin gabapentin side effects and teeth salbutamol information asthma parcopa side effects budesonide side effects liver damage cialis 20mg malaysia novolog insulin sliding scale chart cialis 5 00 mg leukeran drug identification alphagan p 0.15 levitra plus levamisole wormer for sheep pergotime graviditet pletal cilostazol side effects dalacin c 300mg ag guys cialis levitra information advil ingredients motrin ingredients fasigyn tablets information clearing viagra online echeck levofloxacin 500 mg usage generika drugstore website prednisone for dogs with cancer minoxidil 2 solution buy generic viagra from india metallica one tabs dyazide generic name haloperidol injection administration hyzaar side effects hydrochlorothiazide 25mg cialis 10 mg kaufen generic supplier ofviagra the pharmacy express review lumigan 0.03 coupons fluconazole tablet over the counter diltiazem cd ranitidine 300 mg tablet side effect albuterol without prescription hyzaar 50 12.5 price fertomid and clomidfinax viagra super active in canada atarax for anxiety in kids where to buy tulasi plant in uk trimetabol sirop de artar polarmeds complaints against companies para que sirve el antifludes canadian healthcare mall bentyl 10mg cap benicar generic equivalent vermox 500 dosage glipizide 5 mg cost lozol for sale amitiptyline without prescription in uk ventolin inhalers uk low price viagra pills tizanidine hcl 4mg online pharmacy australia free delivery alli slimming cardizem side effects dose zenegra 100 reviews buying with master cardviagra alli walmart cialis france biaxin 500 mg clarithromycin propecia generika 1mg stanozolol cycle dosage furolin medicine park metallica nothing else matters lyrics chords buy isotretinoin online canada ordering domperidone online toradol injection medication propecia fast delivery ebay viagra for sale online black ants viagra florisimide medicine sales midamor diuretic definition celexa side effects in children generic cialis professional 20mg praziquantel for humans viagra pill aldactone 25mg best diet pills canada clavamox for cats for sale zoloft weight gain zoloft side effects proviron mesterolone 25mg buy stromectrol online in canada nuvigil coupons printable viasek 50 mg viagra lidoderm patch uses no prescription online lisinopril hctz costco pharmacy price list viagrs in usa zyprexa for anxiety disorder vytorin side effects cancer is levlen the same as seasonique dostinex side effects cabergoline dosage buy flomax on line no prescription diamox 500 mg sequels buy proplanalol online uk obat azithromycin viagra for men online quick delivery clenbuterol for sale online pramil 50mg stem cells wholesale xenical international purchases capoten drug category hctz 25 mg cheap where to buy indomethacin amlodipine besylate 10mg side effects brand name venlafaxine 75mg er side effects non prescription colored contact lenses clonidine medication for opiate withdrawal motilium retail pharmacy puerto rico trazodone medication side effects rimonabant acomplia fluoxetine 20 mg for dogs only nolvadex for men drug cyclophosphamide cytoxan manufacturer combivent with out prescribtion cuvarlix taken after or before meal prayers parent blog keppra side effects in childrenketalginketazol sinequanone definition of socialism online esomeprazole tamoxifen buy uk irbesartan generic for avapro dermasone cream .025 slimex 15 capsules pergotime 50mg prednisone amoxicillin and clavulanate potassium tablets aldactone for acne reviews insurance company ratings am best canesoral reviews on apidexin nolvadex dosage for men lanoxin side effects digoxin is effexor available in the philippines metoprolol tartrate 50mg tablets pharmn norx where to buy generic viagra in edmonton meds with no prescriptions topamax for migraines reviews flomist nasal spray fluticasone otc viagra what is bactroban side effects roaccutane isotretinoin buy latisse before and after pictures alprazolam et douleur neuropathique benazepril hctz 20 12.5 omeprazole medication for dogs bonadoxina gotas levitra generico vs original uroxatral side effects bph kosovarja numri me i rip what if cialis doesnt work dosage cytotec for abortion buy premarin cefpodoxime vantin side effectsvarfendilvasotec prandin generic available propecia inde cheap viagra overnight shipping where can i get chloroquine antivert 25mg information chinese viagra pills dermasone cream orlistat diet medication proventil without prescription pfizer vgr 100 for sale where to buy cheap viagra online bupropion weight loss dosage how to get antibiotics on the weekend cialis canadian generic over the counter inhaler salbutamol sulfate drug terramycin for chickens buy dostinex tablets no prescription methotrexate prescriptions news where generic propecia manufactured canadian pharmacy codeine generic brand viagra via fedex omaggio olive oil private reserve strain feldene side effects dose retirides .025 cymbalta withdrawal brain zaps marcumar 3 mg online cialis 5mg baclofen 10 mg for pain viagra how to get a prescription wellbutrin dosage amounts amoxil 1g buy xalacom no prescription prescription diet pills doxycycline 100mg capsules how can i buy pain pills online how long do you take prometrium during pregnancy reichlox 500mg vicodin brahmi herbal medicine oxytrol india costco photo center login photo center antibiotics for tooth infection amoxicillin online drugstore canada free shipping reputable online levitra take pueraria mirifica with estrace metoprolol er 25 mg plavix patient assistance application form cuckold definition slang taint remeron for sleep and anxiety canadian healthand care mall lawrence walter pharmwc suprax online ivermectin dosage for dogs with heartworms cheap site viagra lanoxin toxicity symptoms orabet bloger indexoracea viramune 200mg progesterone generic ed meds trimix pricing albuterol nebulizer treatment for infants cialis generic india buying somas from canada cymbalta and provigil reviews cialis in qatar flagyl 400 used for best site to buy cialis oxybutynin chloride 5mg sa elavil dosage for chronic pain flurazepam medication dalmane diarex pro series silicone bracelets budesonide nasal spray and pregnancy benadryl dosage for infants mg/kg phexin boats sale accutane se comprar vardenafil de bayer actos warning risk cialis and viagra professional cytotec online fda zestoretic tabs 10/12 5/6 medrol side effects amazon tretinoin cream clarinase bestellen pinamox suspension kits medyka ukraine protests xalatan patent expiration date therapy dogs inc desyrel 50mg review asthmador powder male enhancement pills viagra cheap vitamin shoppe printable coupons cialis online purchase paypal buying generic viagra online carprofen 100mg pentrexyl 500 mg capsules drug emporium ventolin dosage for infants buy crestor without prescription cheap can u buy clomid on line gpchealth coupons for walmart subutex withdrawal home remedies finasteride london grifulvin v micro 500 tablets carafate side effects sucralfate extenze com capsules seen on tv advantage auto sales loves park il isoniazid pronunciation exercises viagra online germany nootropil 800 information sell of ciprofloxacina doxycycline 100mg no prescription alzytec 10mg methadone lumigan side effects heart my escrow drugs grathazon obat apa piroxicam aldactone side effects zoloft withdrawal symptoms biaxin xl 500mg dosage buy aleve d online phenergan suppository for pregnancy phentermine 37.5mg adipex p laxifen medicina periactin medication cyproheptadine toprol side effects mayo clinic generic suprax buy soft cialis online citrato de sildenafila sandoz best deals on viagra probenecid for gout bactrim dosage for urinary tract infection capoten dosage and administration 24hr cialis cialis generique quel laboratoire reglan and pregnancy rogaine foam reviews minoxidil asthma treatment guidelines order exvromycin 500 no priscption luvox side effects cialis 5mg best price canada provigil vs nuvigil for chronic fatigue lotemax ointment altace ramipril womens viagra canada furosemide 20 mg picture femara infertility success stories buy generic cialas on line clomiphene citrate 50mg side effects valtrex on sai parcopa orally disintegrating tablets praziquantel for cats dosage chlamydia treatment antibiotics for sale online antibiotics tadalafil 20mg uk price how long to get bystolic out of system silagra 100 mg tablets in america anti anxiety drugs canada tadalafil mastercard paroxetine 30mg online india pharmacy vitamix costco 6300 dynamogen ampoules from france strattera reviews for adult add altace 10 mg cap proventil inhaler prices adriana lima fentanyl patches reductil pastile de slabit super viagra without insurance maxaman caye caulker belize accommodations cheapest viagra professional clavamox 500 remeron canada erythromycin suppliers in canada lergigan 25mg ephedrine kenacomb cream uses decadron dosepak directions sildenafil generico in farmacia free synthroid coupons next day express delivery for viagra pilexil sprayway zolpidem 10mg photo insurance adjuster jobs in texas avodart coupon discounts abilify coupons and discounts orlistat 60 mg for sale vantin antibiotic for pneumonia buying cytotec uk januvia side effects with metformin no perscription hydrocodine tricor medication side effects norvasc 10mg gabapentin give energy warfarin and alcohol intake nifedipine ointment treatment viagra suisse ordonnance diazepam dosage for cats viagra 100 precio vicodin side effects vicodin withdrawal symptoms buying ativan in mexico cialis shipped within canada altace medication side effect purchase doxycycline is penegra tablet erect penis zyrtec coupons $5 2013 alli pill for sale in uk nolvadex pills no prescription thyroxine for sale canadian pharmacy amoxal amozon diazepam information buy nolvadex uk bodybuilding can atorvastatin cause hair lost metronidazole or tinidazole side effects ditropan side effects children buy viagra fast delivery permethrin cream 5 for scabies side effects estradot bestellen ohne rezept xalatan eye drops apertium viewers anafranil 10 mg valium kamagra visa octreotide drip rate spiriva handihaler side effects ranbaxy pharmaceuticals recall mebendazole or albendazole cardinal health jobs in texas who makes atrovent inhaler medicineauvitraavalide biaxin 500mg for ear infections best price for generic cialis claritin for children coupon finpecia tablets cipla baristanet montclair nj police department phexin 75070 metronidazole 500 mg obat apa where to find domperidone 2013 usa what are citalopram withdrawal symptoms xenical singapore diazepam 2mg how long does it take to work sibutramine for sale in usa vicodin vs percocet side effects imitrex dosage dose onadron simple triamterene hctz dyazide medication sialis de 5mg viagra kaufen alli where to buy snorting pliva cialis 20mg no prescription 379 cailis furosemide without prescription canada amitriptyline over the counter lamictal for depression lamotrigine digoxin levels birth control overnight delivery fertility pills clomid generic finasteride zyrtec 10mg dosage when to stop nifedipine for preterm labor cheap shop online xeloda effectiveness colon cancer kamagra in usa united states stilnox zolpidem 10mg ketorolaco dosis medicamento celexa withdrawal symptoms duration mentat himalaya forum januvia medication for diabetes zyvoxid 600 mg ibuprofen code red 7 pill does it work viagra vs cialis information betaprofen fc4000rg ovral 21 tablets viagra vpxl online canada qsymia reviews image se puede tomar alchol con septra ds penicillin pills for std for sale software engineer salary google viagra 4 hour warning promethazine 25mg medication ingredients lowest price viagra 100mg form canada is nolvadex legal dentopain fortesta ventolin without rx motrin dosage for children by age otc inhalers walgreens toronto drug stor cabergoline 0.5mg use for bestbuy mexico coversyl perindopril tert butylamine salt vistaril 25mg information jasmine rice levitra pills online septrin dosage syrup xeloda chemo achat viagra en ligne quebec viagra proffesional online australia gupisone 20 tadalafil aurochem 20mg softtabs lexapro and alcohol side effects free forums mexican pharmacy no perscription periactin dose for migraines buy viagra in new york city 123 buy fentanyl patches viagra purchase online with mastercad nizoral cream boots assunzione levitra can you buy viagra over th pramipexole in bodybuilding claritin during pregnancy levitra aus holland walmart pharmacy hours how to order viagra no prescription cardinal health medical products printable maxalt coupons lisinopril 10 mg no prescription stromectol scabies treatment review alesse birth control pill information pravachol blood pressure drugs levitra 100mg guaranteed lowest price omeprazole 20 mg side effects mayo clinic erlamycetin ointment for boils kwikmed competitors redustat 120 mg precio furosemide without prescriptions pharmacy study in canada voltaren 75mg ec indian female viagra vrdrug scammers amantadina para parkinsons medications benoquin powder for sale motrin on line flomax without a rx mometasone furoate ointment .1 zyprexa withdrawal symptoms depression jasmine rice recipe ingredients buy injections online trimix misoprostol induction protocol can i buy fagyl at the pharmacy nexium side effects nexium 40mg santissimo bar mexitil mexiletine medication norstan inc pleasant prairie wi real estate buy amatriptyline buy cialis online with discover card
Consulting Core Services
On-Site Training

GCA can orient the course to any  number of topics but typical ones have included:

  • Basics of the Federal Acquisition Regulation
  • FAR Cost Principles
  • Cost Accounting Standards
  • Working with DCAA
Sample Download

Click to download and view a sample of a recent issue of the GCA REPORT.
Click to download and view  a sample of a recent issue of the GCA DIGEST.

 

Contact Us

Don't hesitate to contact us if you have any questions, comments, suggestions, or problems with registration.

Phone: 1-925-362-0712

Fax: 925-362-0806

Email GCA

Subscriber Login

Path: Consulting Services arrow Report & Digest arrow GCA Digest Articles arrow GCA Digest 1998 arrow Alternatives for the Accounting Treatment of Fringe Benefits

Alternatives for the Accounting Treatment of Fringe Benefits

(Editor’s Note. The firm utilizing only full time employees who are paid generous fringe benefits are becoming the exception rather than the rule. The tough competitive environment of the government market are requiring increasing usage of mixed employment/contract relationships where, for example, temporary and/or offsite employees receiving lower fringe benefits, requiring lower facility and support costs, etc provide opportunities to offer the government lower prices based on lower indirect costs. Our consulting work helping organizations change their direct and indirect rate structure leads us to the unmistakable conclusion that each firm is different and requires a carefully designed approach. We have found the following article in the August CP&A Report by Darrell Oyer, a long time Government contracts consultant and principle of the Darrell J. Oyer & Company, intriguing for illustrating some alternative approaches.)

Fringe benefits costs as a percentage of direct labor has increased substantially in the last ten years. New employment arrangements altering the composition of the workforce has also caused potential variations in indirect cost rates. A brief review of FAR and CAS allocation rules precede a discussion of alternative treatment of fringe benefit costs.

Definition of Fringe Benefits

Fringe benefits are allowances and services provided by a contractor to its employees as compensation in addition to regular wages and salaries. They generally include costs of paid absences for vacations, sick leave, holidays and military leave, employee insurance and supplemental unemployment benefit tax. The US Chamber of Commerce adds (1) legally required payments such as employee FICA taxes (2) retirement and savings plan payments, profit sharing, stock bonuses, Employee Stock Option Plans and defined-benefit and defined contribution pension plans (3) life insurance and death benefit payments (4) medical and medically related payments (5) paid rest periods and (6) miscellaneous benefits such as discount on company products and services, education expense, child care and employee meals.

Allowability

FAR 31.205-6(m) makes the costs of fringe benefits generally allowable to the extent they are reasonable, required by law, employee-employer agreements or are established policy of the contractor. Costs of several types of fringe benefits are subject to separate, detailed allowability criteria (e.g. employee rebate and discount (unallowable), hours and incentive compensation (allowable subject to specified purpose and documentation), pension plans (allowable if computed according to CAS 412 and 413)).

Allocability

FAR 31.201-4 provides general guidance to cost allocations: "a cost is allocable if it is assignable or chargeable to one or more cost objectives on the basis of relative benefits received or other equitable relationship". Since it is difficult to identify fringe benefit costs to a specific contract the allocation criterion is whether a fringe expense benefits both the contract and other work and can be distributed to them in reasonable proportion to the benefits received. FAR 31.203 refines guidelines on allocating indirect costs by stipulating "homogeneous pools" of costs that can be allocated to separate contracts on a similar base should be accumulated while excessive cost grouping may be avoided if substantially similar results are achieved.

The allocation rules provide a wide range of choices for pooling and allocating fringe benefits. The guidance indicates contractors should consider whether the cost pool or pools are homogeneous. If fringe benefits vary substantially between full time and say, less than full time or field personnel, separate fringe pools might be necessary to achieve homogeneous grouping. FAR 31.203(b), on the other hand, stresses it is not necessary to proliferate pools to achieve perfect cost allocation.

Allocation Base

A direct labor dollar base is the usual choice for allocating fringe benefit costs and certainly the preferred choice of government auditors. A different allocation base (e.g. labor hours) may be justified when some fringe benefit costs vary by number of employees (e.g. fixed medical cost) or salary level (e.g. pension). Two separate pools with different bases are usually frowned upon for providing excess complexity with little added benefit.

Cost Pool Alternatives

When a company has primarily full time employees there are various methods of pooling fringe benefits that can yield very different rates and pose various levels of complexity. Fringe benefit costs are usually included as (1) on of many cost elements in various overhead and/or G&A pools or (2) in various separate fringe benefit pools.

Inclusion in the Indirect Cost Pool. Frequently, fringe benefit costs are accumulated with other indirect costs in an appropriate pool such as manufacturing overhead, engineering overhead or general and administrative (G&A). The fringe benefits for both direct and indirect labor are usually included.

The primary benefit of this approach is its simplicity. Lumping all indirect costs including fringe benefits into one or two pools is quite easy. There are two major disadvantages to this approach: (1) fringe benefit costs are not easily identifiable and hence easily monitored and controlled and (2) a higher indirect cost rate results in contrast to including fringe benefits and or other indirect costs in separate pools. For example, an indirect rate of 138% may be viewed more unfavorably than a 100% overhead rate and a 38% fringe benefit rate. As an added incentive, an even lower overhead rate can be made to appear if "direct labor costs" are defined as direct labor dollars plus applied fringe benefit costs.

Allocation of Separate Fringe Cost Pool. A contractor may decide to establish a separate fringe benefit pool to focus management attention of this important cost, to lower indirect cost rates or achieve more precision in its cost allocation methods. Once this decision is made, the contractor must then decide which costs are included in the fringe benefit pool and which costs are in the base.

The discussion below assumes two categories of labor: direct employees who work both direct and indirect functions and indirect employees who work only indirect functions.

Total Fringe Benefits (for direct and indirect labor) with a Direct Labor Base of Direct Employees. If all fringe benefits are in the pool and divided by only direct labor, this approach will yield a high fringe benefits rate because the numerator (total benefits for all employees) is divided by a lower denominator (direct labor only).

Fringe Benefits Costs for Direct Labor Only with a Direct Labor Base of Direct Employees. The lower numerator (fringe benefits for only direct labor) divided over the direct labor base will tend to lower the fringe benefit rate. One problem of this approach is how to handle the fringe benefits of direct labor employees when they perform indirect rate functions (e.g. attending training, idle time).

Fringe Benefits Costs for Direct Labor Only with a Direct Labor Plus Indirect Labor of Direct Employees. Calculate separate fringe benefit rates for direct and indirect employees. When direct employees work directly their fringe benefits are in effect charged to the job worked while when charging indirect, their fringe benefits are charged to an overhead pool like the indirect employees. The advantage of greater precision and a lower fringe benefit is offset against more detailed recordkeeping.

Allocation Through Intermediate Cost Pool. Combine all fringe benefits for all employees in one intermediate cost pool and allocate them on a base of total labor dollars of both direct and indirect employees. Fringe benefit costs are then, in turn, charged either to cost objectives for direct labor or other indirect cost pools. This results in a lower fringe benefit rate and is easy to use but can cause some cost distortion if some employees receive significantly greater salaries and greater fringe benefits (e.g. executives). The distortion can be minimized if fringe benefit rates are similar for all employees or the dollar differences are minimal.

Multiple Fringe Benefit Cost Pools By Employee Category

The increased use of less than full-time employees has created a need for more sophisticated accounting. The use of these employees has created real cost savings (e.g. lower fringe benefits, less support, reductions in idle time disguised as other activities) and contractors need to translate these savings into lower indirect rates for pricing purposes. Full time employees may receive all fringe benefits such as health insurance, vacation, and statutory payroll taxes, part time employees may receive limited fringe benefits such as vacation and statutory payroll taxes while temporary employees may receive only statutory taxes.

One solution for accounting for these varied fringe benefits is to account for them in layers or tiers. As the Table 1 below indicates, the first fringe benefits pool or tier consists of statutory fringe benefits that all employees receive. The second fringe benefit tier could consist of those benefits available to part time and full time employees while the third tier consists of those benefits received only by full time employees. Table 2 illustrates the resulting fringe benefit rate for each class of employee. Contractors can bid temporary employees at 6.93%, part-time employees at 19.43% and full time employees at the full fringe benefit rate of 37.75%.

Multiple fringe benefit pools can also be useful if benefits vary for any reason between different organizational units or facilities. For example, an organization with multistate locations where state employment taxes or different union agreements may require establishing multiple fringe benefit cost pools.

(Editor’s Note. Contractors fully covered by CAS should be aware that changes to their methods or techniques of allocating fringe benefits will likely be considered a change to an accounting practice requiring altering the disclosure statement and possibly triggering the need for a cost impact proposal and negotiating a price adjustments on CAS covered contracts. On the other hand, we have seen instances of a different treatment of fringe benefits by new categories of employees considered as an adoption of a new accounting practice, averting the claim of a change to an old practice. This discussion is beyond the scope of this article and competent CAS experts should be consulted.)

{TAG_FORM_TITLE}

To discuss your needs, contact Bill Lennett, Principal, at 1-925-362-0712 or email him at This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it .

*
 
*
 
*
 
 
*
 
 

 
GCA Subscription
REPORT FEATURES
  • New Developments-Rule Changes, New Guidelines, Court Decisions
  • Feature article for Small/New Contractors
  • Practical Q&A Sections

Download & View Sample


DIGEST FEATURES
  • Experts' Discussion of "HOT" Contracting Issues
  • Analyzing a Cost Principle or Cost Accounting Standard
  • Pricing Strategies
  • Case Studies on Challenges to Government Findings

Download & View Sample


SUBSCRIBER BENEFITS
  • Free use of our "Ask the Experts" panel where subscribers can submit questions to or chat with our network of eminent consultants and attorneys.
  • Electronic access to all prior newsletters through 2000. We provide state-of-the-art word search Word and linked electronic index to all articles.
  • Mailed hard copies and electronic versions will provide timely access to all newsletters.

 Learn More

 Subscribe